Sunday, February 16, 2014

Review: Society6 Casemate iPhone case

The Knight of Swords by Noelle Stevenson

The back of my phone is a perfect opportunity to carry around a little piece of art. What the case looks like is honestly the first consideration when I'm shopping. Secondary is how well the case will function and hold up to wear and tear. I also like to rigorously research things I spend my money on. I was miffed last year when I could not find a review of Society6's cases other than fresh out of the mail. I don't know if they were not out long enough for anyone to have an opinion or if no one really saw the point, or what. 

I bought one anyway because what it looks like is most important to me and I was completely in love with the Knight of Swords by Noelle Stevenson.

A year and some months later, this is the review of Society6's Casemate case printing I wish I had.

The printing on the back is nice and the colors are true. However, the printing on the sides is poor and it fades to white (the color of the plastic) towards the front.

Over the course of the year the paint has rubbed off the corners and edges. It took about 8 months before it became noticeable.

At 12 months it went from noticeable to disreputable looking.

Debris inside the case.

The case started out very secure on the phone. Quickly (a few months) it because slightly loose. Just loose enough to get debris caught inside the case where it rubbed the metal and damaged my phone. I don't take the case off very often, so I don't think it was anything I did to stretch it out.

The pits in the metal go all the way around.

I drop my phone at least once a week. With only a little bit of damage to the case, it's protected my phone from concrete, tiles, and my own stupidity. It finally broke last week near the buttons (exactly where I'd been expecting a break) after a nasty drop. As far as durability goes, the case has definitely saved my butt. It's not exactly an Otter Box, but it does pretty freakin' good for one of the thinnest cases I've seen.

It doesn't do anything to protect the front, so I employed plastic sticky screen covers, which works well.

In comparison:

My sister-in-law bought her phone case around the same time as mine. She got hers from RedBubble.

Her case has held up great. It's a tight fit (though her's is obviously a different kind of case than mine). The ridge on the top edge protects the screen from rough surfaces. And most importantly (to me), except for the corner that tangled with concrete, the art is 100% intact (though the glossy protective layer has scrubbed off a little).

In conclusion
If forty dollars isn't anything to you, and you want to change your case out every 6 or 7 months, Society6's phone cases are for you.

However, forty bucks is a lot to me, and I was disappointed. I was hoping to carry around a little piece of art that would hold up over time and protect my phone. My phone's pretty protected, but the body's also scratched from the loose fit, and now the printing is degrading. While I was very glad to carry around Noelle Stevenson's art, I doubt I will buy a Society6 case again. 


  1. Thank you for publishing this review. It has been so hard to find reviews for either the Society6 or Redbubble cases! I really appreciate it.

  2. Thanks for this review! I definitely should've read up some before buying. Mine just arrived and I'm pretty disappointed with the quality considering the price I paid. :/ Like you said, I don't think I'll be buying their cases again.

  3. We provide the largest selection of smart phone cases, covers and cases for tablets. For all the top brands from Galaxy to iPhone. All items are made in house and shipped in 2 business days. We also provide custom orders with any image you provide. best iphone case

  4. Thanks for such an awesome article. Why not have a look at Happy diwali 2015 blog and know how can one celebrate a very good happy diwali.

  5. Thanks for sharing the valuable information,This is useful information for online learners

    iPhone 5 Cases

  6. Great information
    Videocon offers a wide range of mobile handsets with great data plans for both prepaid and postpaid mobiles.

  7. This written piece gives fastidious understanding yet.

    buy iPhone cases online

  8. Very Interesting Story !
    You may like to buy custom iphone cases in your budget price...

  9. metal cover protect to the mother board best iPhone covers from outer viruses.....

  10. Browse our great range of protective phone accessories, cell phone accessories and iPhone 6s cases. The most intelligent impact protection for your Apple device

  11. Nice review. You can also get better iphone cases at

  12. Enjoy the lowest prices and best collection of iPhone case covers ever only at Kase because style is what matters with iPhone covers quality.